Friday, June 22, 2012

Questionable

Even knowing that this is a trick question....even having seen it before.....I still got it wrong.

Here’s a simple arithmetic question: 

A bat and ball cost a dollar and ten cents. The bat costs a dollar more than the ball. How much does the ball cost?

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

I'm afraid to answer although the answer seems obvious to me. I can't answer because I might be wrong and if I'm wrong I'd be a failure. I'm afraid to fail.

Cerulean Bill said...

To me, the answer is obvious, too. Even doing the math quickly, its obvious. Its just wrong.


Everyone thinks Oh, thats obvious - a dollar for the bat, ten cents for the ball. But its not. This is how you solve it.

Given - Cost of Bat + Cost of Ball = $1.10

The Cost of the Bat is $1 more than the Cost of the Ball, so
Cost of Bat = Cost of Ball + $1
or to show it a little differently)
Cost of Bat = (Cost of Ball + $1)

Since the Cost of Bat = (Cost of Ball + $1) (because we know that the bat costs a dollar more than the ball), you can substitute in the first equation, and change
Cost of Bat + Cost of Ball = $1.10
to
(Cost of Ball + $1) + Cost of Ball = $1.10.

Subtract one dollar from each side -

(Cost of Ball) + Cost of Ball = 0.10

Since you have two 'Cost of Balls' being equal to ten cents, that is the same as saying
2*Cost of Ball = 0.10.

If two 'Cost of Ball's is ten cents, then one Cost of Ball is five cents. And if the Ball is five cents, and the Bat + Ball is $1.10, then the Bat must be $1.05 -- which is one dollar more than the ball.

Unknown said...

I had it at a nickel!

How I figured it out was: bat = $1
Difference = $1

Therefore, the ball can't cost 10c, because then the cost would be $1.20; the ball has to cost less than that. So... divide and conquer - if the bat cost $1.05 (half way between $1 and $1.10) then... Good grief I figured it out! :-)

Cerulean Bill said...

You did much better than I, CA.